A father accused of battering his six-year-old daughter to
death rang 999 two hours after she had died and told them she had
‘fallen’, a court has heard.
When emergency services arrived at the home of Ben Butler and Jennie Gray, they found Ellie Butler in her pink pyjamas lying on the floor, with Peppa Pig still playing in the background.
Her head had been smashed in.
Her parents, both 36, called 999 two hours after she was fatally hurt while home alone with her father and another child on October 28. 2013, a court has heard.
The prosecution has said a post-mortem examination ruled out an accidental fall and her death was put down to Butler either beating her over the head with a heavy object or throwing her against the floor or wall.
Butler, from Sutton, denies Ellie’s murder and both he and Gray have pleaded not guilty to child cruelty over an earlier shoulder injury.
Gray has admitted perverting the course of justice by hiding or destroying evidence after she rushed home from work an hour before the 999 call.
She told an operator: ‘It’s my daughter, she’s not breathing.’
In the background, Butler could be heard saying Ellie has ‘fallen down’.
Once responders arrived, Ellie was found to be ‘very cold and blue’ with no heartbeat.
First responder Sarah Hardy told the court: ‘I asked again what had happened to her and I believe her dad said “I don’t know. I thought she was in her bedroom sleeping”‘.
Earlier, the court heard from two neighbours who saw Butler outside the family house just 15 minutes before the emergency call.
Marion Cook said Gray later broke down and told her Ellie ‘fell off her bed and hit her head on a radiator.’
The trial continues.
When emergency services arrived at the home of Ben Butler and Jennie Gray, they found Ellie Butler in her pink pyjamas lying on the floor, with Peppa Pig still playing in the background.
Her head had been smashed in.
Her parents, both 36, called 999 two hours after she was fatally hurt while home alone with her father and another child on October 28. 2013, a court has heard.
The prosecution has said a post-mortem examination ruled out an accidental fall and her death was put down to Butler either beating her over the head with a heavy object or throwing her against the floor or wall.
Butler, from Sutton, denies Ellie’s murder and both he and Gray have pleaded not guilty to child cruelty over an earlier shoulder injury.
Gray has admitted perverting the course of justice by hiding or destroying evidence after she rushed home from work an hour before the 999 call.
She told an operator: ‘It’s my daughter, she’s not breathing.’
In the background, Butler could be heard saying Ellie has ‘fallen down’.
Once responders arrived, Ellie was found to be ‘very cold and blue’ with no heartbeat.
First responder Sarah Hardy told the court: ‘I asked again what had happened to her and I believe her dad said “I don’t know. I thought she was in her bedroom sleeping”‘.
More medics arrived and they continued to try to save Ellie but there was no response.
It was only when ambulance crew member
Penny Robson looked at the back of Ellie’s head that she stumbled upon a
‘boggy mass’ at the back of it.
She also described seeing fluid coming from the child’s mouth or nose.Earlier, the court heard from two neighbours who saw Butler outside the family house just 15 minutes before the emergency call.
Marion Cook said Gray later broke down and told her Ellie ‘fell off her bed and hit her head on a radiator.’
The trial continues.
No comments:
Post a Comment